The One Piece TCG mulligan: when to keep and when to redraw
One redraw, all five cards, no partial keeps — which makes the mulligan decision unusually clean and unusually punishing.
The short version
- You draw five cards and may mulligan exactly once, shuffling your entire hand back and drawing five new cards.
- The mulligan is all or nothing: you cannot keep some cards and replace others, and the new hand is still five cards with no penalty.
- Because there is no card penalty for mulliganing, the bar for keeping a hand is higher in One Piece than in games that shrink your hand.
- A keepable hand normally has at least two cards you can play on curve in the first three turns.
- Hands full of expensive cards are the classic trap: they look powerful and do nothing for four turns.
One Piece has the friendliest mulligan rule in any major card game, and most players still get it wrong — in the direction of keeping too much.
The rule, precisely
- Both players draw five cards at setup.
- Each player may mulligan once.
- A mulligan shuffles your entire hand back into the deck. You cannot keep part of it.
- You then draw five new cards — the same number, with no penalty.
What a keepable hand looks like
Your first turns have very little DON!! to work with — one on turn one if you are the first player, two if you are second, and rising by one each turn. A hand is functional if it lets you use most of that DON!! on most of those turns.
| Hand | Verdict | Reasoning |
|---|---|---|
| Two cheap Characters, one mid-cost, two Counter-heavy cards | Keep | Plays on curve, defends while you develop. This is the shape you want |
| One 1-cost, one 2-cost, three cards costing 6+ | Keep | Two early plays is enough; the expensive cards become Counters if the game goes badly |
| Five cards, none costing under 4 | Mulligan | You do nothing for three turns against a deck that is developing every turn |
| Four cheap Characters and nothing else | Marginal | You will run out of gas by turn four, but you get to play the game. Keep on the play, consider mulliganing on the draw |
| Two copies of the same expensive card plus three Events | Mulligan | Redundancy at the wrong cost tier is not depth |
| One perfect card and four blanks | Mulligan | One card does not win a game of One Piece. This is the hand people keep and regret |
The heuristic
Can I make a reasonable play on two of my first three turns? If yes, keep. If no, mulligan. Everything else is refinement.
That single question resolves the vast majority of hands correctly. The refinements below matter at the margins.
Refinements
On the play versus on the draw
Going first, you skip your draw and get one DON!! — so your hand has to be self-sufficient for longer, and a hand with only one early play is worse. Going second, you draw immediately and have two DON!!, so a slightly slower hand is more defensible. Keep marginally looser on the draw. Going first or second covers why the two positions differ so much.
Counter values are part of the hand
A card you cannot cast is not necessarily a dead card: most cards carry a Counter value and can be discarded during the Counter step to save a Character or your Leader. A hand of expensive cards with high Counter values is meaningfully better than a hand of expensive cards without them — see the Counter step.
Know what your deck needs to start
Some Leaders are built around an engine card and are much weaker without it. Others are happy with any two bodies. Before an event, shuffle up and draw twenty opening hands to learn what your specific deck considers functional. This is the single most useful ten minutes of practice available.
Do not mulligan for a specific card
Throwing away a functional hand hoping to find one card is how you lose to your own deck. Mulligan because the hand cannot operate, never because it lacks a favourite.
The 15-second routine
Count your playable turns
How many of the first three turns can you actually use? Two or more is a keep.
Check the cost spread
All expensive is a mulligan. All cheap is a marginal keep. A spread is a keep.
Look at Counter values
A slow hand with high Counters survives long enough to become a fast one.
Factor in turn order
Tighter on the play, looser on the draw.
Decide and do not revisit
You get one. Second-guessing after the redraw is wasted attention that belongs on the game.
After the mulligan
The new hand is what you have — there is no second redraw, and a bad second hand is not a reason to play differently out of frustration. Play it as though you had drawn it first. Tilting after a bad mulligan loses more games than the mulligan does.
Frequently asked questions
- How many mulligans do you get in One Piece TCG?
- Exactly one. Each player may mulligan once at the start of the game, shuffling their whole five-card hand back into the deck and drawing five new cards.
- Do you lose a card when you mulligan in One Piece TCG?
- No. Unlike Magic: The Gathering, the replacement hand is still five cards. There is no penalty beyond the risk that the new hand is worse.
- Can you keep some cards when you mulligan?
- No. The mulligan is all or nothing — your entire hand goes back into the deck and is reshuffled before you draw five new cards.
- When should you mulligan in One Piece TCG?
- Mulligan when you cannot make a reasonable play on at least two of your first three turns. In practice that means hands where every card is expensive, or where you have only one playable card.
- Should I mulligan differently going first?
- Yes, slightly. The first player skips their first draw and places only one DON!!, so a hand needs to be more self-sufficient. Keep tighter on the play and slightly looser on the draw.
Sources
Stop guessing what your cards are worth
Bounty scans a card down to the exact variant and prices it against TCGPlayer, Cardmarket and Yuyu-tei. Free on iPhone, five scans a day.
